So, you’re planning a trip and are wondering where to stay. Your two main options are to rent an Airbnb or book a hotel room. It’s impossible for me to pick a favorite since they both have different pros and cons. In making your decision, there’s a lot to consider. I have compiled a pros and cons list below to help you decide which is the best option for your upcoming trip. If you have any other pros and cons, or disagree with any of mine, please leave me a comment below! I’d love to hear what you think.
Hotels
From my experience, some hotels are nicer and newer than others, but the typical hotel stay is pretty generic and one I think most people are familiar with. You check in at a front desk, they give you a room key, and your room is usually furnished with a bed, tv, desk, mini fridge and a bathroom with some miniature toiletries. Housekeeping refreshes your room, replaces your towels, removes your trash and makes your bed each day. You may order room service, spend time in the gym or by the pool, but you pretty much come and go. Hotel stays are pretty predictable and reliable. You all know what I’m talking about.
Let’s look at some of the pros of renting a hotel vs. an Airbnb:
- Can be cheaper, especially for a small group, unless you stay in a single-room Airbnb. I am not a hotel snob, don’t tend to hang out on hotel properties and generally can find a hotel for $65-$150 a night almost anywhere I’ve looked. Reward memberships and discounts can also make this a cheaper option as well. I have seen a lot of reviews that say the opposite, but that has absolutely not been the case for me. My only guess is that they are searching in different cities than I have been to, wont stay in a $70 hotel or are splitting the cost of an Airbnb with others.
- 24/7 Access & Assistance: In the event that you need assistance, you will usually have people on property to help troubleshoot whatever comes up. If you need to switch to a different room or something needs to be replaced or repaired, it can usually be handled pretty quickly.
Hotel stay cons:
- Predictable, reliable, generic: If you like knowing what to expect, this might be a pro to you, however, certainty doesn’t really call to my gypsy spirit.
- Little to no privacy: I’ve never been the only guest on property at a hotel. There are always people within eye and ear-shot. This can be a con if you’re looking for a romantic dip in the pool, have young children, or want to have a late night get together anywhere other than your own hotel room.
Airbnb:
If you are not familiar with Airbnb, it is simply a website that allows individuals to rent out their properties, rooms, RVs, train cars, treehouses, camp spots etc. to people, short or long term. An Airbnb experience is anything but routine and generic. If you have never used with Airbnb, read through to find out more of what you might expect! I also want to mention, there are several websites similar to Airbnb, and I assume these pros and cons would apply to those types of rentals as well.
Pros:
- Unique accommodations and amenities: Airbnbs are better known as being more than just a place to shower and lay your head while away from home. I usually seek out Airbnbs when I want more of an experience. Just to give you an idea of what I mean, I have rented a vintage travel trailer with a fire pit, hammocks and outdoor bath for an evening, a yurt treehouse on a goat farm with a hot tub for a romantic getaway, a mother-in-law suite with a pool for a girls’ trip and single rooms in larger, sometimes historic, homes for solo trips.
- Personal touches and curated guidebooks: Most of the Airbnbs I have stayed in have had unique personal collections and touches left by the owner. Some will leave out candy, postcards, stickers with the house logo, etc. These little touches just give off a warmer feeling than the note pad and free plastic pen you might find in a hotel. Additionally, I think we all are familiar with the stands in most hotel lobbies full of brochures from local attractions, but in an Airbnb you will most always find a book that not only includes information and history of your location or home, but a well thought-out guidebook to the area. Another personal touch I have found in most Airbnbs is some form of a guestbook or map you can add a note, pin, or Polaroid photo to. I traveled to Savannah and left a Polaroid on a fridge and months later someone recognized us and sent a picture of it to our friend! It’s fun to get to an Airbnb and see what is waiting for you and they are very well known for these thoughtful personal touches.
- Opportunity to connect with your host or other guests: If meeting other travelers and locals sounds appealing to you, you might enjoy an Airbnb experience over a hotel. Often you can share a home or property with other guests who likely also enjoy the same things as you.
- Privacy: This is not always the case, but you have better options available if you are seeking privacy if you rent an entire home versus one hotel room of 100.
- Ideal for families or big rowdy groups: An Airbnb can be better for a big group, family or rowdy bunch when it comes to cost and again, the privacy. An Airbnb also gives you an option for more beds and more bathrooms for your group and some allow or provide extra air mattresses.
- Experience a place like a local and have a more authentic experience: Airbnb had a campaign called Live There that showcased this exact principle. With Airbnb, you get to live in a location and experience the city from a local’s point of view. For more cultural or foreign locations, this could get very interesting!
- Lots of reviews to help you chose the right rental: Scroll through any established Airbnb rental and you will see plenty of reviews from real people who will leave their own pros and cons on a listing. It is usually these reviews that help persuade me to book a specific property. I read every single one once I’ve booked and be sure not to miss anything another guest recommends I see, do, or bring.
- Wider option of amenities: You can find a wide and often unique range of amenities like a washer and dryer, private pool, kayaks, outdoor baths, hot tubs, fire pits, bicycles, grills, a full kitchen and all you would need to cook, if that’s what you want. You will not find that in a hotel!
Cons:
- Cleanliness: I hate to put this one on there, but Airbnbs are not always super clean like a hotel is. Don’t get me wrong, I’ve never seen a dirty rental, but since it’s a home, it usually tends to have some dust in places a hotel just wouldn’t or have a less than luxurious bathroom fixtures. Again, no problems, but if you’re a clean freak, Airbnb might not appeal to you anyways.
- You are the maid! You’re expected to clean up and put everything back where you found it and then they charge you a cleaning fee! I don’t leave anywhere an absolute mess, but in an Airbnb you are expected to make the extra effort to put everything back, do your dishes, clean up all trash, and some even expect you to make the bed before you go.
- Added fees and costs: Sometimes $100 plus! I already discussed the cleaning fee, but a listing for $40 on Airbnb can easily become $100 plus. Just be aware.
- No room service and your host might not even be in the same country: Just keep this in mind and be flexible in case the WIFI is out or the a/c breaks.
That wraps up my pros and cons list and comparison of Airbnbs vs. hotels. Which would you chose, or neither and why? I’d love to know!